Once you've tried handmade marshmallows you'll never go back to the mass-produced kind. These, from Butter Baked Goods in Vancouver, B.C., are made with all-natural ingredients, and have a lighter-than-air texture and just enough vanilla to make them interesting. Drop one in your hot chocolate, use them to make gourmet s'mores, or just eat them straight out of the bag—they're that good.

Ten Marshmallows, 5 oz. total